What you can see in a snail

Moving on my (slimy) side-track of trying to identify land snails on paintings and other works of visual arts, I found something interesting related to European snails. By the end of the Middle Ages religious motifs were still very much ‘en vogue‘ in visual arts. Italian painters were especially good at this theme, and one of them was Francesco del Cossa (c. 1430/1435 – 1477). He worked in Ferrara in northern Italy and made c. 1470/1472 the work ‘Annuncio’, which is now in the Staatliche Kunstsammlungen in Dresden.

You see in the foreground a snail on the move to the right; you can’t deny, it’s so obvious. Catching the eye… But to my knowledge this is the first painting where a snail is pictured in such great detail if you zoom into it. Art historians have attached different symbolic meanings to snails; in the case of this painting the iconographic snail would exemplifying “the perpetual virginity of Mary” (Ettlinger, 1978). But I also found a different, well-written opinion in a book by the French art historian Aresse (see Waters, 2008), who believes the snail “makes you understand that you are seeing nothing in what you are looking at”. Food for art historians…

Anyway, what species are we seeing here? According to Aresse this is “a good old Burgundy snail” [i.e. Helix pomatia]. But I don’t think it is what Aresse thought he was seeing. Why would a painter in northern Italy use a French species he might even not have known? Would it be not more plausible to use a species that could be locally obtained? If so, we need to look at the Italian malacofauna. In Cesari (1978) I found a shell very similar to the one in Cossa’s work; pl. 5 fig. 1 shows Helix cincta Müller, 1774 from the same area where Cossa worked. The same broad pale band along the suture and a small one on the periphery. That is what I see in this snail.

Later in time we see that more painters started to use these ‘domestic commodities’. But that’s quite another story…

References:
Cesari, P. (1978). La malacofauna del territorio Italiano (Note di aggiornamento e diffusione conoscitiva), 1o contributo: il genere Helix. — Conchiglie (Milano) 14: 35–90.
Ettlinger, H.S. (1978). The virgin snail. — Journal of the Warburg and Courtauld Institutes 41: 316.
Waters, A. (2008). The snail’s gaze. Available at http://intranslation.brooklynrail.org/french/the-snail’s-gaze.

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “What you can see in a snail

  1. Ondrej

    …and the very small apex characteristic for H. cincta is also depicted precisely. But I wonder, why the foot is so red – this species has a pale greyish foot, as far as I know.

    Reply
  2. bramb Post author

    I don’t think the painter had the intention to make a fully accurate illustration of this snail as for a biology textbook. This was made c. 1470…; it is already miraculous that we can identify it at species level, compared to other paintings of that time.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s